When it comes to crafting a marketing strategy, too many marketers get caught up in chasing trends and forget the most valuable source of insight: your past experiences. Every failed campaign, every successful one—it all holds critical data that, if leveraged correctly, can shape a truly exciting and effective strategy. But this isn’t just abou003t crunching numbers. It’s about intuition and a feeling you can’t quite put into words. As Richard Mechaly from Provoke Agency says, “Strategy is the ability to come up with an idea that excites you…it’s an internal feeling where you’re like, yeah, that’s hot.”
Let’s break down how to use the lessons of your past to craft an experience-driven marketing strategy that’s both exciting and effective.
View this post on Instagram
Learn from What Worked (and What Didn’t)
We often focus on what didn’t work, but let’s not overlook your successes. The campaigns that hit the mark should serve as your blueprint moving forward. What messaging resonated with your audience? Which channels generated the most engagement? What kind of tone, visuals, and calls-to-action sparked action?
At the same time, failures are gold mines. Every failed campaign holds valuable lessons if you’re willing to analyze it objectively. Instead of brushing off poor performance, dive deeper into the “why.” Did your targeting miss the mark? Was the messaging unclear? Did your follow-up strategy fall short?
Evaluate your data with these critical questions:
- Which campaigns yielded the highest ROI, and why?
- Where did engagement drop off in the marketing funnel?
- What patterns do you see across your top-performing content?
By understanding both sides of the equation, you’ll have a clear roadmap of what to replicate and what to avoid in your next campaign.
Monitor Marketing KPIs But Don’t Ignore Intuition
We live in an era dominated by data—and rightfully so. Metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates are essential to informing a marketing strategy. But data alone isn’t enough. Your intuition and experience play a vital role in turning cold numbers into something meaningful.
Sometimes, you can look at the numbers and still feel like something’s off. That’s when your experience, and those gut feelings, come into play. You’ve worked with a variety of clients, industries, and products, and you know what resonates with an audience beyond the stats. Combine data-driven decision-making with your intuitive understanding of what works.
“The best strategies aren’t always built solely from numbers; they come from instinct honed by years of trial and error.”
Creating a Email Marketing Strategy Using Past Experiences
Here’s a step-by-step guide for transforming your past campaigns into an exciting and effective new marketing strategy:
1. Review and Analyze Past Campaigns
Start by reviewing your previous marketing efforts, whether email campaigns, social media pushes, or paid ads. Collect all relevant metrics and customer feedback. Dig into what drove conversions and where customers lost interest. Were there timing issues? Did your audience engage with certain types of content more than others?
Many marketers obsess over what went wrong, but what about your successes? Most people don’t dig deep enough into why a particular campaign worked. You didn’t just stumble upon success by chance—there was something in your approach that hit home with your audience.
Ask yourself:
- Was it your messaging?
- Did the timing align with market demand?
- Was there something specific about your audience that made the campaign resonate?
Dig into the specifics and apply those elements across future campaigns.
2. Segment Your Data by Campaign Type
Break down your past campaigns into categories such as email marketing, social media ads, or content marketing. This segmentation allows you to see what worked best in each medium and helps tailor your next strategy to the most effective platforms.
3. Identify Patterns and Trends
Now that you’ve segmented your data, look for patterns and trends across campaigns. Did your audience react more positively to campaigns with a personal touch or ones driven by urgency? Understanding these preferences is critical to building future messaging.
4. Turn Failures into Actionable Insights
Remember, failures are teachers. If a particular strategy didn’t perform well, identify what went wrong. Did you target the wrong audience? Did your messaging confuse rather than clarify? Failures shouldn’t scare you—they should empower you to improve. Apply these lessons directly to your future strategies to avoid repeat mistakes.
5. A/B Testing as a Safety Net
Even when basing your strategy on past successes, remember that A/B testing should be a constant. Don’t assume that what worked last year will always work. Test small changes like subject lines, visuals, or calls to action to continuously refine your approach.
Bringing It All Together
The best marketing strategies come from a blend of intuition and hard data, with a heavy dose of past experience. Don’t just rely on the metrics to tell you what to do next—listen to your gut, and learn from both your wins and your losses. As the reel says, “It’s usually backed up by certain experiences, past successes…there’s a feel for the industry.”
When building your next marketing strategy, remember this: data gives you the map, but intuition gives you the direction. Let your past campaigns guide your next steps and infuse your strategy with the excitement that comes from knowing you’re on the right path.